Respiration, Note Taking, and Grading

High school teachers have a responsibility not only to teach content but also to teach skills.  One of the most critical life skills is note-taking, and it is often neglected in our curriculum because teachers are either unwilling to sacrifice class time to teach note-taking or they believe that it is not in their job description because students should already know how to take notes from middle school.  Some teachers prepare fill-in-the blank worksheets believing that such an activity will help students take notes, but enabling children to rely on someone else’s organization instead of developing their own teaches students to be passive and dependent learners.  This post will focus on how to teach students to retain difficult and detailed content via note-taking.

As a seasoned teacher I have witnessed that the quality of student notes directly correlates with performance, and note-taking begins and ends at home.  Although homework is becoming a hot topic and there is a movement to eliminate it altogether, all of my experience shows note processing at home is critical for success.

There are four stages of note-taking:

  1.  Pre-note homework (priming)
  2. Class lecture notes
  3. Post-note homework
  4. Maintenance homework

This blog will illustrate each of these stages using AP Biology’s aerobic respiration material.

Pre-notes

Pre-notes are critical to provide a foundation of basic knowledge on which to scaffold the details.  Pearson’s Campbell Biology is an excellent resource.  Pages 163-181 regarding cellular respiration are dense, long, and have an incredible amount of detail.  As much as I support textbook reading, through experience I have learned that asking students to complete the reading above prior to lecture is premature.  More and more students lack the ability to even process such technical information, let alone express it in their own words, and to assign 20 pages all at once before they have had any exposure to the topic typically overwhelms them.  For pre-lecture notes I suggest a shorter primer like this one.  I assess their notes the next day not only to keep students accountable but also to train them in efficiency.  At the beginning of the year I spend a great deal of time modeling effective notes and offering extensive feedback on student attempts.  So many students take pages and pages of notes that are literally sentences copied from the source.  I emphasize to them that if their notes have no pictures and are copied sentences, then they have wasted their time, and they will retain very little information since they failed to reprocess the content in their own words.  Here are my pre-notes on the primer above that I would model to the students to help guide them in my expectations:

1

Lecture Notes:

Following pre-notes are lecture notes.  A lecture should be interactive, image based, and have minimal words.  The more words on the screen, the more students are copying verbatim and only using one area of their brain.  When students are not given the words to copy they are being forced to listen, reprocess the information into their own words, ask questions, and then record their personal understanding experience.  With little to no words in presentations they will get so much more out of the discussion because they are integrating input from all over their brain.  This Google Slide presentation models lecture notes and activities.

Post-Notes:

I suggest students use the lecture notes as well as the Campbell pages (Pages 163-181 will not be as overwhelming at this point due to their exposure to the material) and merge the two sources together to develop comprehensive post-notes.  This time their notes should be much longer, and it is still critical that they contain images and are in their own words.  They should look like something like these:

23456last

 

The next day in class it is important to review the material one more time in small and large group discussions before moving on to the lab, and the Google presentation linked above walks through those activities.   The AP biology lab can be found here.

Maintenance:

At this point students have been exposed to all the content, and they must retain it at least until the test which is usually a week or two down the road.  Evidence shows that to retain information students must continue to revisit the material.  (See image below.  The blue line illustrates how regular small time investments result in greater long-term content retention).  I emphasize to students that reviewing material is not staring at notes because most people cannot look at a piece of paper and burn the information directly into their brain.  Reviewing the material should be an active process.

Screenshot 2016-02-20 18.45.51 copy

For active reviewing I developed something I simply call “chunk notes” which involves folding a piece of notebook paper into quadrants (chunks) and labelling each section with a unit term.  One piece of paper allows for 8 concepts (front and back). Each box has to contain 5 individually constructed bullet points as well as a picture to receive credit.

After a lot of trial and error I have found this to be the most efficient way for students to review and retain material without overwhelming them.  I assign chunk notes on weekends, and although they hate it (who wants homework on weekends), it is once a week so regular enough, it shouldn’t take them that long, and it is time well spent.

Note in this example of chunk notes (these are just the first 8 terms I thought of, but anything from the unit would be just as effective) that there can and will be a lot of repetition which is totally fine.  The more they write something, the more likely they are to remember it.

xy

By the time the students take the test they have processed every single objective of cellular respiration in multiple ways, including reading, large group lecture and discussion, small group analysis, as well as individual practice.  The last piece of this blog will be devoted to grading.

Daily Grading: Credit Card/Soft grades (mostly effort)

My grading philosophy is multi-tiered and non-traditional.  First of all, my daily grades are soft grades that really only involve following directions.  I do not pore over soft grade assignments with fine a tooth comb checking for accuracy (time-saver).  These grades consist of glances and are recorded in a “credit card”.  For example on day one, as class is getting started, I walk around and see if they have done the pre-notes.  If so, they get a stamp, and if not they get an x.  Simple as that.

IMG_3693 copy

The credit card above is how I break down the respiration unit.  Pre-notes are important so I assign them two boxes, one for quality, and one for pictures (as mentioned above, if biology notes are words with no images, they are not effective).  Post-notes are even more important so I assign them three boxes, and for those I look for quantity and inclusiveness in addition to quality and pictures.  The daily work (ticket out, Venn diagram warm-up, and round robin ticket out essay, which are all described in the Google Slide presentation) are included as incentives for students to do high quality work (it is an all or nothing check).  Students need to be held accountable, and the credit card method keeps them on track.  Note that not one of the activities is a worksheet.  I do NOT give busy work because it is a waste of their time to do it and a waste of my time to grade it.  My credit cards consist of either 10 or 20 boxes for easy grading (time-saver).

Quiz Grading: Concept Checks/Hard-grades (accuracy)

I wish I could simply take grades on effort, but that is not realistic.  Students also need to be held accountable for learning, not just doing, and to do that I simply give 10 question concept checks.  They are usually something I come up with the day before and are hand-written because I always include figures and do not want to spend the time generating and formatting them on the computer.  Teaching is a juggling job, and my philosophy is “work smarter not harder”.  Will spending an hour making a digital concept check when you can write the same one in ten minutes affect student content retention?  If the answer is no, I always do the time-saver.  Another time-saver is to ask students to switch papers and grade each others upon completion as I go over the answers.  To prevent cheating, I always emphasize that if they bump points on their partners, I dock those points from their own grade as well as fixing their partners.  Of course I look over the grading afterwards to confirm accurate grades, but I hardly ever have to adjust because in the discussion they ask for clarification if they are not sure about an answer.  This peer grading serves two purposes:  it gives them immediate feedback on the assignment and allows them to ask questions while also facilitating quick grading.  I usually do about two per unit and their grade can either be the average or the higher of the two.  See the example below:

IMG_3688 copyIMG_3689 copy

Answers:

IMG_3691 copy

 

IMG_3692 copy

Efficiency of soft and hard grades:

As a new teacher I spent so much time grading district worksheets that were busy work and no time grading notes.  I struggled for a long time with that because worksheet grades did not correlate with student test scores at all (they are easy to copy and low-level) while the quality of class notes did.   I knew that note-taking and individually processing information is the single most important skill regarding content-retention, so after a few years, I stopped grading the worksheets and I started the credit card.  The credit card gave me a vehicle to grade notes, give feedback on notes, and encourage students to do meaningful work and high-level activities.  Once I stopped grading busy work and started the credit card system my student test scores increased dramatically.

Hard grades are equally as important as soft grades because it would be doing students a disservice to not give them any accuracy grades prior to a test.  Students need to practice taking assessments, and concept checks give them that opportunity while also being convenient to grade.

My soft and hard grading system works so well for both students and teachers.  It helps them to be successful while minimizing time spent grading.  In my experience students are more successful when teachers spend the time to develop meaningful lessons, create interactive PowerPoints, and give individual feedback as opposed to using their time to grade busy work.

Grading unit assessments:

Test grades consist of lab write-ups, the unit test, and/or a unit project, and I will discuss examples and my philosophy on those in the next post.

 

 

 

 

Superbowl, the Double Dip, and Seinfeld

Superbowl Sunday parties are a blast, especially when your team wins (ahem, Denver Broncos).  An article here utilized as a student warm-up can be an engaging introduction to a lesson on microorganisms and disease.   It has a pop culture component and links NFL “fun facts” to the flu, and it serves as a primer for complicated content.  If football is not your bag there are so many other opportunities for “fun” when introducing pathogens, and finding a pop-culture “hook” is well worth the time.

Students probably don’t know about Jerry Seinfeld and his crew of characters (I am aging myself, as this was a funny sitcom in the 1990s), but even without the prior knowledge, they will certainly find these little clips funny.  See clips 1, 2, and 3

Here is another humorous article that debunks a ridiculous notion that beards are disgusting bacteria-fests.

150505_SCI_BeardRed.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumlarge

However the pathogen unit is initiated, I highly recommend starting with something relatable and funny because the content is going to get downright “hairy” and far surpass student background knowledge.

Following the quick introduction, content delivery comes next, and I direct students to complete a detailed foldable called “The Good, The Bad, and The Pretty”, meaning they have to identify beneficial microorganisms, detrimental microorganisms, and draw pretty and labeled pictures of them.  Their job is to read and extrapolate information from their textbooks, and yes, I still have students read from the textbook.  It is a critical life skill to read detailed information and not only to differentiate critical content from noise, but also to process the information by constructing unique explanations that aren’t verbatim duplicates of the source.  Many teachers veer away from the textbook because “students can’t or won’t do it”, but to deprive students of this skill is doing them a disservice.  Reading comprehension should not be the primary method of content delivery by any means, but it certainly should be weaved into the curriculum at conducive opportunities for student practice of this critical skill.

The foldable activity involves reading from the textbook, recording details in a graphic organizer-like chart, and designing comprehensive figures.  I give instructions that each panel needs to discuss Bacteria, Protists, and Fungi (viruses are not technically organisms so I don’t introduce them yet) in at least three bullet points that have 4 words or less.  I do not accept sentences or phrases copied from the book.  I tell students if they cannot break the point down into four words or less, then they need to process further until they can.  To differentiate for higher level students, I have modified their instructions so that every bullet point must have exactly four words, and that keeps them from finishing in 2 minutes while simultaneously reinforcing the material by requiring longer processing times.

Einstein

I also require students to draw a cell of each kingdom and label at least 6 structures in each figure.  I chunk this activity and have them work independently for 15ish minutes.  It is critical that at the beginning of this activity they use their own skill-sets and work independently.  After about 15ish minutes, I allow them to walk around the room to ask their peers questions and to look at other’s work for examples.  This is critical for modeling and differentiating because unfortunately there are students at the high school level that simply lack reading and extrapolating skills.  The opportunity for the weaker students to see models of high-quality work and for the stronger students to process content verbally, thereby reinforcing it, benefits both populations.  After the five minute break, students have 5-10 more minutes to incorporate information and complete their foldables, then lecture begins.  From start to finish, their work should look like this (except they should have pictures included).

1

Screenshot 2016-02-10 12.28.22 copy

Many teachers cringe at the concept of lectures because as technology is further incorporated into pedagogy (as it should be), old-school strategies are frowned upon. Lecture need not be  traditional “teacher talk & student copy” though.  Meaningful and highly effective presentations are deliberately designed with minimal words, image analysis, and the incorporation of appropriate processing breaks.  Like textbook reading, lecture should be integrated into any teacher’s classroom, not all the time, but occasionally, in order for students to practice note taking.  If students are not exposed to the art of listening to explanations and asking questions for clarification, they are missing a critical piece of education, which is to prepare them for life.

The foldable is my diving-board into the lecture, and I spend a lot of time making it engaging, like a ted-talk.  I start with a picture of bacteria like this one, focus on the details I want students to remember, and integrate memorable details, in this case maybe discussing a friend of mine’s mom who was in the hospital for over a month with a bacterial infection.  I deliver content without spoon-feeding them the words while taking the time to make sure that every student has the opportunity to include the details in their notes in case they missed them.

bacteria copy

After bacteria, delivery of information on protists then fungus is the same, again giving every student the opportunity to fill in gaps and ask questions.

structure-euglena-anatomy-freshwater-protozoan-composed-chlorophyll-has-rudimentary-eye-vector-diagram-34424805nri1255-i1

Following lecture, to wrap up the lesson, a critical piece is to raise students to the analysis level, and figure analysis is one of the most effective closure activities in biology.  Sometimes I deliberately “mess-up”, and then use it to my advantage.  For example, at the end of this particular lecture I could post these foldable images and  ask students to identify two important points regarding each cell type, any goofs, and two possible interesting additions that could be added to each picture.  This analysis and extension involves small group discussion followed by an opportunity for me to stretch them for high quality answers in a large group discussion.

The students always wow me with what they notice and interpret.  In this type of activity, after hearing all of their answers, I reveal my thoughts as well, providing a nice wrap-up.

Screenshot 2016-02-10 11.58.46 copy.png

  • BACTERIA:
  • Important: no nucleus, prokaryotic like Archae, super small
  • Goof: Bacteria have very large circular central chromosomes in the nucleoid region, the smaller circular DNA are plasmids
  • Extension: Could add bacteriophage infecting it
  • PROTIST
  • Important: eukaryote so way larger and more complicated than bacteria, mostly single celled
  • Goof: This is obviously a plant cell due to its square shape and cell wall of cellulose.
  • Extension: Should have animal-like, plant-like, and fungus-like all in picture
  • FUNGUS
  • Important:  heterotroph and should never have a chloroplast
  • Goof:  over-simplified cell missing some structures
  • Extension:  Could draw multi-cellular mushroom with hyphae and mycelia

 

 

This post discussed the importance of note-taking and lecture style.  The next one will include more details on student notes as well as a lecture an example via Google Slides.

Diabetes, frogsicles, and #singfornicole

When people think of diabetes many of them associate it with obesity, which is actually correlated with only type 2 diabetes.  This post will focus specifically on type 1 diabetes, which is an endocrine system problem.  The endocrine system, as any biology teacher knows, involves delivery of hormones.  I never know when high school students walk into my classroom if they know anything about hormones other than that testosterone and estrogen makes them have massive make-out sessions in the hallways and elsewhere.  I don’t know if they know about growth hormone’s affect on development, adrenaline’s fight or flight effect, or the importance of insulin.

They do come with a preliminary knowledge of the digestive system, as shown in the video here.

digestion video

As shown so graphically, the mouth and stomach mechanically and chemically digest food.  Enzymes in our saliva start the breakdown (delighting our tastebuds) and the enzymes in the stomach, not the acid, is what actually further digests food.  The acid simply allows the enzymes to shape correctly, otherwise mis-folding occurs, rendering the protein useless.   The stomach acid is also for defense purposes, as it is inhospitable to other living organisms and can destroy microbes that we unknowingly ingest.

What I don’t think students have considered is that the journey continues.  The video does a fabulous job of showing the post-stomach digestion as well as the villi, the hair like projections that significantly increase the surface area of the small intestine.  Their job is like that of a towel, to increase efficiency of soaking up material (the fluffier the towel, the more effective).  The soaked in sugar is then transferred into the circulatory system and delivered to every single cell in our body, which is critical because our cells cannot function without food.  The pancreas, a low profile organ, plays a vital role in what comes next.

islets_of_Langerhans

website source

Most of the pancreas functions as an exocrine gland, meaning its secretions don’t circulate with blood like hormones.  Its function is to deliver digestive enzymes directly into the small intestine.  The rest of the pancreas, the endocrine portion, consists of the isles of Langerhans, literally little islands scattered throughout the pancreas.  These islets contain beta cells that secrete insulin and alpha cells that secrete glucagon.  These hormones have opposite functions and both are critical for blood sugar regulation.

The glucose sucked in the blood by the small intestine is far too big to diffuse across a cell membrane.  It needs a channel protein to pass, and the insulin secreted by beta cells in the pancreas acts like a key that allows that gate to open and let glucose in.  See here for an article that describes this action in detail.  The picture below gives a great visual.

type-2-diabetes

So, if cells need food and insulin opens the gate for food to enter, why are these gates regulated?  Why do they ever close?  They close because if glucose isn’t in the blood, it can’t feed brain cells, and if brain cells lack food, they stop working.  If there is not enough glucose in the blood to be delivered to the neurons in the brain, hypoglycemia results and the consequences are disastrous.  If low blood sugar does not get treated, it will result in death.  I had a student a few years ago whose sister died in her sleep from hypoglycemia, and it broke my heart.  If you click on this link,#singfornicole, read her story, and then press the play button, you will understand.

Here is a very simple movie that I used to show to my 9th graders because it has such great visuals at the cellular level.  It is low level and simplistic but can be a fabulous intro and provide an engaging opportunity for extension.  If they watch this video, then design a paper or project on how it could have been made higher-level, it would be an excellent analysis and synthesis level activity that reinforces the content.

easy diabetes movie

Occasionally, people without diabetes can feel hypoglycemic and a little dizzy.  Most likely what is happening is that the balancing hormone glucagon is delayed for some reason. Glucagon is actually present and functions correctly in diabetics, although it cannot be effective with sustained hypoglycemia.

Glucagon’s role in blood sugar management is to stimulate the liver to secrete glycogen, an animal starch (complex carbohydrate) that has long chains with branches of glucose.  It is like an emergency sugar reserve. If the liver dumping glycogen into the bloodstream is ineffective and blood sugar continues to plummet, seizures can occur, a last attempt by the body to release sugar via muscle contractions (muscles are high energy using cells and have sugar reserves as well).  I knew a man who had diabetic seizures occasionally, and after every one, he would have these things I called “eye spots”, little red dots surrounding his eyes.  I never knew why, but later I looked it up and as it turns out, it is actually  petechia, a condition arising from severe physical trauma.

Here is a website that features this image and offers a fabulous overview on how insulin and glucagon normally coordinate.

c45x10glu-homeostasis

Diabetics not only have to worry about hypoglycemia, but if they fail to take enough insulin and hypergylcemia results, consequences can be just as deadly.  Severe hyperglycemia will result in coma and eventually death because the starving cells have no access to energy and stop metabolizing.

With diabetes, it is possible to live with bouts of hyperglycemia that are treated before becoming life-threatening, but after years of sustained high blood sugar, even if it is on and off, it can be detrimental.  You might have heard that diabetes is associated with foot amputations, which is true for a variety of reasons.  First, with a lack of insulin cells are starved, and they have no access to fuel.  Also, high blood sugar is thick and over time will harden and constrict small blood vessels (capillaries) resulting in poor circulation.  Starved neurons result in nerve damage and decreased sensation.  People with desensitized feet can injure them and not know which can cause infection and deformities.  Diabetes is also associated with blindness because perpetual high blood sugar can similarly constrict the capillaries of the eye, depriving it of critical materials.

I honestly don’t know how this disease can even exist.  Pre-pharmaceutical industry, there was no insulin for treatment.  How could our ancestors have survived this disease long enough to pass the gene onto children?  I know it is a delayed onset and can arise in childhood, but how many 10 year olds are having babies?  It is not just genetic though, it has been proven that that there is an environmental component as well.  There is a book that suggests maybe diabetes could provide a selective advantage in certain environmental conditions.  If that is true, then the gene could have arisen in a specific population, then spread as humans became more mobile.  Chapter 2 of a book called Survival of the Sickest by Dr. Sharon Moalem offers a compelling argument that diabetes has a selective advantage in colder climates.  Her hypothesis is supported by its overrepresentation in cold regions (Finland, Sweden, and Norway) and the existence of a wood frog that utilizes high blood sugar like antifreeze to prevent from hypothermia.  She discusses the wood frog, Rana sylvatica, that externally freezes solid in cold weather after drastically elevating its blood sugar to maintain cellular osmolarity, then comes back to life when it defrosts.  I am not kidding.  Check out this video.

However diabetes entered our gene pool, it is a tragic disease.  Great news is that with treatment, it can be managed.

1922 was when insulin was first used on a patient.  The discovery resulted in a Nobel Prize shortly after (see article).  Now, there are insulin pumps, which mimic pancreas activity by delivering low, basal, rates of insulin with the ability to administer high doses with meals.  Insulin shot therapy is an alternative treatment, and there is long acting insulin designed to provide that basal, low dosage, then rapid acting insulin administered with meals.  Shots are less predictable than insulin pumps making it slightly more difficult to maintain stability, but they are less expensive, making them an attractive choice for therapy.  Additionally, there is the ability to monitor blood sugar levels with finger pricks that release a drop of blood and are analyzed by a small machine.  There are also constant glucose monitoring systems that can be worn and synced to smart devices to deliver alarms, but they are expensive.

There are also more advanced therapies that are in the process of being developed.  Islet transplants are an experimental procedure, and here is a scholarly explanation, but as a scientist, I see two fundamental problems with it.  First, diabetes is an autoimmune disease, it is when the body destroys its own beta cells.  If there is something about the cells that the immune system recognizes, which is a real possibility, it seems likely that the body would destroy the transplanted cells.  Also, any organ donation means the recipient has to take immunosupressants for life so that their immune system does not destroy the foreign cells.  Is it worth taking immunosupressants and facing vulnerability to other illnesses when diabetes can be managed with a pump?

There are also hopes of developing an artificial pancreas, which seems impossible to me, but 20 years from now it might very well the preferred treatment, if people can afford it.

pancrease picture